
I received my first piece of criticism concerning my blog early this week. It startled me a bit and set me just a few paces back. I’ve only personally given this blog address to my family members and a few friends with the sole intent of building up the courage to share it openly.
I love my idea intensely which is probably why any criticism this early on is bound to hurt. Maybe I shouldn’t have been so open with my “tell me what you think” until I was truly ready to hear what people think.
In my quest for support I instead received some somewhat harsh words:
“It sounds like you’re doing some major soul searching these days”
This just set a condescending tone for me to read with.
“…But I don’t know what advice a random person is going to be able to give you. It seems like only someone who knew you and your situation well would be able to give relevant advice. And if you don’t know the person, it would be hard to tell if they would give good advice. Maybe they’re flighty or a poor decision maker”
The whole point is that I want random advice. I want to see what pours my way. I’m excited to see what’s out there beyond people that relate to me. I’ll use what pertains to my life and all the extra I might pass on to someone else. And if it’s super flighty advice that’ll just make for a good story to put into my archive. I’m not trying to take it intensely serious.
“You said in your blog that you wanted people to share experiences that they learned the hard way so you could avoid making the same mistakes. But an important part of life IS making mistakes. That’s how you really learn and grow. You can’t do that through other people’s stories.”
She makes an obvious point, however I don’t plan on living my life through other people’s experiences. A guy my husband works with had a rock hit him in the knee while riding his motorcycle on the highway. It severely bruised him even through the hard padding of his riding pants. That week my husband went out and bought protective riding gear. Now, a rock may never hit him in the knee, but at least he’s better protected now. That’s a mistake that I don’t care for him to learn on his own.
“You also said that you’d like to think that people aren’t harsh, critical, and judgmental like you used to assume… it’s rare that you find someone that’s not judgmental. It’s just human nature.”
I refuse to believe this one. The end!
Now that I have defended my beautiful idea I can say that I do appreciate my friend’s honesty. She made me realize how passionately attached I am to this concept of accepting a stranger’s advice while ridding my mind of clutter. And constant cynicism. The email that originally felt like a punch to the gut actually reignited my love for this blog!!